What Homes in St. Pete Actually Look Like: Old, New, and In Between

We were walking through a 1941 bungalow in Crescent Heights when Aubrey grabbed my arm and said, 'This is the one I would pick.' The wood floors creaked under our feet, the ceilings were low, the kitchen was tiny -- and she was right. The home had more character in its front porch than most new builds have in the entire floor plan.

That home went under contract 17 days later. And the thing is, it wasn't even the most practical house we toured that week. But it made people feel something, and in St. Pete, that matters -- because the housing stock here is wildly different from anything most buyers have seen before.

In this video and guide, me and Aubrey walk through three completely different homes -- a 1920s wood-frame bungalow, a 1950s block construction ranch, and a brand-new townhome in the Edge District. Three different eras, three different price points, three different lifestyles. If you're relocating to St. Pete, you need to understand all three before you write an offer on any of them.

The 1940s Bungalow in Crescent Heights

Let me take you back to that Crescent Heights walk. The home was built in 1941. Three bedrooms, two baths, roughly 1,567 square feet on a 7,700 square foot lot. Listed at $789,000.

The first thing I noticed walking up was there's no front garage. The garage is in the back off the alley -- which is super common in these older St. Pete neighborhoods. Most of the historic homes in Crescent Heights have an entrance from the front and an entrance from the back via an alley. And honestly, the curb appeal you get without a big garage door staring at you from the street? I kind of love that.

Inside, every single window had been replaced -- double-pane, energy-efficient. New roof. Original wood floors that were genuinely beautiful, not the kind where you're wondering what's hiding underneath. The trim work, the character, the way light hit those rooms -- you can't manufacture that. These homes were built with old-growth wood that is denser and more durable than anything available in modern construction.

And here's what really matters for your wallet: because every window had been replaced, the homeowner qualified for a break on their wind mitigation. That directly lowers your insurance premium. On a wood-frame home in Florida, updated windows aren't just an aesthetic upgrade -- they're a financial one.

Why the Good Ones Don't Sit

That home went under contract in 17 days. No bidding war, no circus -- the listing agent just called me and said, 'Hey, we got an offer in.' It wasn't that a hundred people were competing. It's that when something genuinely good hits the market in a walkable St. Pete neighborhood -- updated systems, more than one bathroom, a layout that actually works -- someone who knows what they're looking at moves on it.

And that's the key phrase: a layout that actually works. Finding a historic bungalow in St. Pete with three bedrooms, two bathrooms, and rooms big enough to put actual furniture in is rare. Most of these homes were built as two-bed, one-bath with tiny closets and chopped-up floor plans. The Crescent Heights home was the exception. That rarity is a big part of why it moved at $789K.

What to Actually Look for in a Wood-Frame Home

Most of these bungalows sit on a crawl space with a concrete or block foundation underneath and wood-frame construction above. They have a ton of character, but they've been here for almost a hundred years. So before you fall in love with the porch, here's what I check first:

• Electrical panels -- if the home still has old Zinsco or Federal Pacific panels, you may not be able to get homeowners insurance at all. Non-negotiable.
• Roof age -- insurance companies in Florida care deeply about this. A roof over 15 to 20 years old can spike your premiums or limit coverage options.
• Windows -- upgraded double-pane or impact-rated windows qualify you for wind mitigation discounts. On a wood-frame home, those discounts can save you thousands per year.
• Plumbing -- many of these homes were built with galvanized or cast iron pipes. If it hasn't been updated, you're looking at an $8,000 to $15,000 re-pipe.
• Water heater age -- easy to overlook, but older water heaters are a red flag for insurers and one of the simplest things to check during a walkthrough.

Here's my honest take: you absolutely do not need new construction to get a great home in St. Pete. These historic homes were built with craftsmanship and materials that don't exist in modern construction. But you need to buy one that's been properly updated where it counts. A bungalow with new windows, a newer roof, and updated electrical can have perfectly reasonable insurance. One that's been neglected in those areas can cost you a fortune -- or be completely uninsurable.

The Alley, the Garage, and the House Hack

Standing in the back alley of that Crescent Heights property, I started nerding out a little. Because if you're interested in house hacking or building an ADU -- an additional dwelling unit -- these lots are set up perfectly for it. St. Pete allows 800 square feet of additional living space. Most people put it right on top of the garage. That way you keep your garage and add a rental unit above it.

There were two parking pads in the back -- one for you, one for a tenant. Even in the densest parts of the city, you're not stuck with only street parking. And these setups make great one-month-plus rentals too, though there are rules around short-term rentals you need to know before going that route.

The Block Construction Ranch in Disston Heights

We drove about ten minutes from Crescent Heights to Disston Heights, and the vibe completely changed. No brick-paved streets. Nothing walkable nearby. But the second we pulled up to this block construction ranch, I turned to Aubrey and said, 'This is the one I'd tell a first-time buyer to seriously look at.'

Two bedrooms, one bath, roughly 1,100 square feet. Listed at $379,000. Block construction, block foundation, gutters all around, extended lanai, fully fenced yard, solid garage. Nothing flashy. But solid in every way that actually matters when you're buying a home in Florida.

Why Block Construction Changes the Math

This is one of the most important things to understand when buying in St. Pete, and it's something most out-of-state buyers have never thought about. In Florida, your construction type directly impacts your insurance premiums. Block construction -- concrete block walls on a concrete slab -- costs meaningfully less to insure than wood-frame.

The reasons are straightforward. You don't have to worry about the subfloor. You don't have to worry about massive termite damage. You don't have to worry about water intrusion the same way -- though block is still porous, so you do need to stay on top of maintenance. But the peace of mind during hurricane season is real. You're in a solid concrete structure. Over 30 years of ownership, the insurance difference between block and wood-frame can add up to tens of thousands of dollars.

And here's the elevation angle: Disston Heights sits at roughly 60 feet above sea level -- among the highest ground in all of St. Pete. That means most of these homes are in Flood Zone X. No mandatory flood insurance. Between the block construction and the elevation, your insurance profile in Disston Heights is about as good as it gets in Pinellas County.

The One-Bathroom Problem

Now I have to be straight with you. The single biggest drawback of these 1950s block homes is the layout. Almost every single one was built as a two-bedroom, one-bath. That was just the standard in the 1950s.

Aubrey was very clear about this when we were house hunting for ourselves -- one bathroom was a dealbreaker. And she's not alone. It is the number one reason I see buyers pass on otherwise great block homes. If you have guests, a roommate, or a growing family, sharing one bathroom is just a pain.

So what people do is they put a second bathroom in the garage. And this is where I need you to pay close attention. I have seen people do it really well -- they finish the space, move the garage wall in, air condition it, connect the plumbing properly, install a real ceiling. That works. That genuinely transforms the home.

I have also seen people literally throw a toilet in the corner of an open, un-air-conditioned garage with exposed rafters and call it a 'second bathroom' on the listing. During a Florida summer, nobody wants to use that. If a listing for a 1950s block home claims two baths, inspect that second bath very carefully.

The Kitchen Reno That Changes Everything

The kitchens in these homes are almost always small and walled off. But because they're concrete block, many of the interior walls are non-load-bearing -- which means you can open them up.

One of our past clients, Melinda, did exactly this in Disston Heights. She moved the fridge, cut out the wall between the kitchen and living room, added an island, and the transformation was dramatic. What had been a cramped, dark kitchen became an open, bright living space that felt twice the size. It made it so much easier to put a TV in, to optimize the layout, to actually live in the home. If you're willing to invest $15,000 to $30,000 in a kitchen renovation at this price point, the value you create is substantial.

The Value Case for Disston Heights

I know this type of home is not going to appeal to most people on paper. But here's what I need you to understand: at $379K, block construction, highest elevation in St. Pete, Flood Zone X, ten minutes from the beach, ten minutes from downtown -- this is where you get maximum value. If you're a first-time buyer, an investor, or someone who wants low carrying costs and is willing to put in some work over time, these block construction neighborhoods are the smartest play in St. Pete right now.

New Construction Townhomes in the Edge District

For the final walkthrough, we headed to the Towns at Union by David Weekly Homes, right off Central Avenue in the Edge District. This is the option for buyers who want new construction but refuse to give up St. Pete walkability.

Three bedrooms, three-and-a-half baths, two-car garage. 1,952 square feet. Priced at $634,990. And at the time we toured, David Weekly was running a promo -- $30,000 off for cash buyers, or a reduced rate and closing cost assistance if you're financing. Those kinds of incentives only exist in new construction.

The Insurance Structure That Surprises People

The HOA is $300 a month. Before you react to that number, hear what it includes: sewer, trash, water, and all exterior maintenance -- the roof, the siding, the paint, the landscaping. The only area you're responsible for is inside your fenced patio.

Because the association carries the building insurance and handles the exterior, your personal insurance policy is much closer to renter's insurance. You're basically insuring your contents and personal liability, not the structure. For buyers coming from states where homeowners insurance is a predictable, minor expense, this removes the single biggest source of sticker shock in Florida real estate. Not in a flood zone, either.

What David Weekly Actually Delivers

Walking through, a few things stood out. They use a lot of windows -- bigger windows, higher door frames -- so the natural light is excellent. Higher ceilings, gourmet kitchen with a gas range, solid countertops. The living room was wide and genuinely spacious. And the double-pane, sound-optimized windows are no joke. Fifth Avenue is right outside, and you cannot hear the traffic from inside. In a lot of the older homes around St. Pete, especially with original windows, you're definitely hearing that road.

One thing I loved about the floor plan is they put a full bedroom on the ground floor. With multigenerational living on the rise, having a downstairs bedroom is huge -- whether it's for older family members, someone who can't do stairs, or just a guest suite that doesn't require climbing to the third floor.

• First floor is block construction, upper floors are wood-frame -- you get block durability at ground level where it matters most for storms.
• Full bedroom on the ground floor for multigenerational living or accessibility.
• Double-pane, sound-optimized windows standard throughout.
• All finishes are pre-selected -- this is a spec home, not a custom build. Any changes happen after closing.
• Finished garage floor included, which almost no builders do.

The spec-home approach is a tradeoff. You can't customize before closing like you might with David Weekly in Parrish. But you can walk through and touch exactly what you're buying. No guessing. No waiting months for a build. For some buyers, that certainty is actually the selling point.

How Walkability Connects to Where You Buy

Understanding these three home types only gets you halfway. The other half is understanding that where each type sits in St. Pete determines your entire daily lifestyle. And it comes down to two roads and one interstate.

Central Avenue runs east to west -- it's the heartbeat of St. Pete. Restaurants, coffee shops, breweries, local businesses the entire length. Fourth Street runs north to south and anchors the other axis of walkable life -- Trader Joe's, Sunken Gardens, and a growing stretch of shops along MLK as well.

In the video, me and Aubrey actually took Lime scooters from the Edge District all the way down Central Avenue to the pier. Then we rode the Sun Runner -- the public transit bus -- back to the Edge District. It took maybe five minutes. They run every fifteen minutes. Honestly, we were both impressed. The bus was clean, efficient, and you can literally park your bike on it. If I lived in the Edge District, I'd use it all the time.

The I-275 Dividing Line

Here's the simplest way to think about it. East of I-275, you're in the walkable zone. That's where the bungalows in Kenwood and Crescent Heights are, the townhomes in the Edge District, the homes near Crescent Lake. You can bike, scooter, or take the Sun Runner to most things you need.

West of I-275, you're in the value and space zone. Disston Heights, Jungle Terrace, Allendale, Greater Pinellas Point, Pasadena, Seminole -- tons of options. You're driving everywhere, but you're typically ten to fifteen minutes from downtown and ten to fifteen minutes from the beaches. And you're getting significantly more house and lot for your money.

Quick Reference: Three Home Types Compared

• 1920s-40s wood-frame bungalow: $580K to $800K+ in walkable neighborhoods. Tons of character, but higher insurance, smaller layouts, and you must verify updates to electrical, roof, and windows.
• 1950s-60s block construction ranch: $350K to $500K in Disston Heights and surrounding areas. Lower insurance, hurricane-durable, highest elevation in St. Pete. Typically two-bed, one-bath with dated kitchens. Best value play in the city.
• New construction townhome: $600K to $650K in the Edge District. Lowest personal insurance, modern finishes, walkable location. HOA covers exterior maintenance and building insurance. Best option for buyers who want new and walkable.
• Insurance ranking from lowest to highest annual cost: new construction townhome, block construction ranch, well-updated wood-frame bungalow, neglected wood-frame bungalow.

How to Decide Which One Is Right for You

After helping over 50 buyers find homes in this market, I'll tell you the framework we walk every client through. It comes down to three questions.

First -- how important is walkability? If walking to dinner, biking to the farmers market, and living without depending on a car is central to why you're moving to St. Pete, you need to be east of I-275. That means a bungalow in Kenwood or Crescent Heights, or a townhome in the Edge District.

Second -- how sensitive are you to insurance costs? If keeping your monthly carrying costs low is the priority, block construction in Disston Heights or a new construction townhome with association-covered exterior insurance will serve you best. Wood-frame bungalows can have reasonable insurance if updated, but they'll never be as cheap to insure as block.

Third -- how much renovation are you willing to take on? If you want move-in ready with zero projects, go new construction. If you have vision and budget for a kitchen reno or bathroom addition, block construction offers the best return on investment. If you love the idea of preserving a piece of history and the home's already been properly updated, the bungalows deliver a living experience you simply cannot replicate.

The best advice I can give you is this -- do not commit to one type of home before you've seen all three in person. Tour a bungalow. Tour a block ranch. Tour a townhome. You'll know within the first five minutes of each walkthrough which one feels right.

If you're planning a move to St. Pete -- whether it's next month or next year -- we'd love to help you figure this out. We put out videos every week on Wednesday, and if you want to talk through what type of home makes sense for your situation, reach out anytime. That first conversation is free and it saves weeks of guesswork.

Watch the Full Video

Watch the full video on our YouTube channel